TAX INVOICE VS. BILL OF SUPPLY: WHICH DOCUMENT SHOULD YOU ISSUE?
Published by ArthMitra 360 Knowledge Desk | Status: Educational Draft (Unpublished) ---1. The Core Dilemma for Indian Small Businesses
One of the most frequent points of confusion among small shopkeepers, grocery merchants, and freelancers registered under GST is choosing between a Tax Invoice and a Bill of Supply. Issuing the wrong document can invalidate your customer's tax credits, distort your GSTR-1 filings, and invite scrutiny from the GST department. This practical guide breaks down the legal differences under Sections 31(1) and 31(3)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017, helping you pick the right format instantly. ---2. Comparative Matrix: Tax Invoice vs. Bill of Supply
| Feature / Dimension | Tax Invoice (Section 31(1)) | Bill of Supply (Section 31(3)(c)) | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Primary Purpose | Used to charge GST on taxable goods and pass on Input Tax Credit (ITC) to the buyer. | Used when no GST is charged or when the seller is legally barred from collecting tax. | | Who Issues It? | Regular GST Registered Taxpayers supplying taxable goods or services. | 1. Composition Scheme Taxpayers (under Section 10).2. Sellers dealing in 100% Exempted Goods (e.g. unbranded grains, fresh milk, fruits).
3. Unregistered micro-merchants below the GST threshold. | | Is GST Charged? | YES. Tax rate (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%) and CGST/SGST/IGST amounts must be explicitly shown. | NO. Zero tax is levied. Collecting GST on a Bill of Supply is a statutory offense. | | Can Buyer Claim ITC? | YES. Registered B2B buyers can claim Input Tax Credit against this document. | NO. The buyer cannot claim any tax credit on a Bill of Supply. | | Mandatory Title Declaration | Must be prominently titled: "TAX INVOICE". | Must state: "BILL OF SUPPLY".
For Composition dealers: "Composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies." | | HSN Code Requirement | Mandatory 4-digit or 6-digit HSN based on annual turnover. | Recommended for inventory classification, but tax rate column is omitted. | | Consecutive Numbering | Up to 16 alphanumeric characters, unique per financial year. | Same rule: Up to 16 alphanumeric characters, unique per financial year. | ---
3. When Must You Issue a Tax Invoice?
You must issue a Tax Invoice if: 1. You are registered as a Regular Taxpayer under GST. 2. The items you are selling attract a non-zero GST rate (e.g. packaged goods, soaps, electronics, stationery, clothing). 3. You are supplying goods to another registered business (B2B) who requires an invoice to claim credit, or to a retail consumer (B2C). ---4. When Must You Issue a Bill of Supply?
You must issue a Bill of Supply in any of the following three scenarios:Scenario A: You Opted for the GST Composition Scheme
Merchants enrolled under the Composition Scheme (turnover up to ₹1.5 Crore for manufacturers/traders, or ₹50 Lakh for restaurants/service providers) pay a flat 1% to 5% tax from their own pocket. By law, Composition dealers are forbidden from collecting tax from their customers. Therefore, every document they issue to customers must be a Bill of Supply.Scenario B: You Are Selling 100% Tax-Exempt Goods
Even if you are a Regular GST taxpayer, if a transaction consists entirely of nil-rated or exempt items (e.g. fresh vegetables, unpackaged foodgrains, unbranded curd, curd, raw milk), you must issue a Bill of Supply rather than a Tax Invoice.Scenario C: You Are an Unregistered Micro-Merchant
If your annual turnover is below the GST registration threshold (₹40 Lakh for goods in normal states, ₹20 Lakh in special states), you do not have a GSTIN. Any billing document you give to customers is technically an informal retail bill or Bill of Supply without tax components. ---5. What is an Invoice-cum-Bill of Supply?
What happens if a customer buys both taxable goods (e.g. branded shampoo @ 18% GST) and exempt goods (e.g. fresh bread / milk @ 0% GST) in a single shopping cart? Under Rule 46A of the CGST Rules, you do not need to print two separate slips. You can issue a single "Invoice-cum-Bill of Supply", which itemizes the taxable items with their respective GST rates and segregates the exempt items without tax. ---6. How ArthMitra 360 Handles Both Formats Seamlessly
In ArthMitra 360, switching between document types requires zero reconfiguration: - One-Click Toggle: Select "Tax Invoice" for regular taxable B2B/B2C billing, or toggle to "Bill of Supply" for Composition or exempt sales. - Automatic Title & Disclaimer Injection: The correct statutory header and composition declaration are automatically formatted on both A4 PDFs and 58mm/80mm thermal receipts. - Zero Calculation Errors: Tax rates are automatically suppressed on Bills of Supply, eliminating the risk of accidental illegal tax collection. --- Disclaimer: This guide is intended for educational purposes under the CGST Act, 2017. Consult your tax consultant or Chartered Accountant to verify your specific business classification.Ready to test thermal printing with your printer?
ArthMitra 360 generates both 58mm and 80mm continuous thermal receipt PDFs for free.
Open Free Billing App →